Today we
have written to the Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak.
Dear
Prime Minister
We ask you to take urgent action to halt an
escalating campaign of violence and intimidation against women in the name of
“trans rights”. Women
are being threatened with social ostracism, loss of livelihood and physical
violence; shouted down and intimidated at public events; and even subjected to
physical violence – all for insisting on their freedom of belief and
freedom of expression, and calling for existing sex-based legal protections to
be upheld.
We urge your government to issue a call for
evidence and to commission a rapid review on the impact of extreme
transactivism on women’s rights, as it has done with other emerging threats to civil liberties and the
democratic order. This will enable you to identify the specific actions that
must be taken by the police, Crown Prosecution Service, courts and prisons to
ensure that women’s rights are upheld.
Escalating threats
The
campaign of intimidation and violence against women has been obvious for some
time. The latest shocking example came on 31st August, when a violent criminal
was acquitted on charges of inciting violence against women, despite video
evidence.
At the
Trans+Pride rally in London on 8th July, Sarah Jane (formerly Alan) Baker, who
served 30 years in prison for horrific crimes, including kidnapping, torture
and attempted murder, told the crowd: “If you see a TERF, punch them in the
fucking face.” This incitement, and the response of the whooping, cheering
crowd, were captured on film.
“TERF”
stands for trans-exclusionary radical feminist. It is a slur often accompanied
by misogynistic and sexualised threats. It is used against women who recognise
the fact that men commit violence at greater rates than women, and that men
cannot become women by changing their name, clothing or parts of their anatomy.
This belief is also termed “gender critical”.
Initially,
the Metropolitan Police brushed off women’s complaints about Baker’s threatening
words. Only after multiple complaints from women and a public outcry did they
arrest Baker. Despite his history of extreme violence and the evidence captured
on video, the court accepted his explanation that his words were a “joke”,
merely intended to get him some publicity and newspaper headlines.
A criminal justice system that is
failing women
A woman
did not commit kidnap, torture and attempted murder, spend 30 years in prison
for these crimes and then dedicate her days to rabble-rousing against women who
defend their rights and will not be silent.
A man
did.
Similarly,
the criminal justice system panders to rapists, child abusers and other violent
men who demand to be referred to as women. It demands at every step that these
men’s victims comply with this language, concealing the truth of male violence.
When
women try to speak in public, the police fail to protect them from mobs of
shouting, shoving, frightening men. When women are assaulted by these men, the
police and Crown Prosecution Service are reluctant to bring charges. When a
charge is brought, as we have seen with Baker, the courts fail to recognise the
severity of the crime, or that it is part of a wider campaign of intimidation.
A
whistleblower in the Metropolitan Police has revealed that at an official event
for “Trans Day of Remembrance”, a speaker told officers that anyone concerned
about transgender ideology was a bully and bigot motivated by hate. Officers
booed and hissed when a well-known women’s-rights campaigner was mentioned.
This dismissal
of women’s victimisation is familiar to all women who campaign against male
violence. Police dismiss domestic violence as “both sides” and regard women as
bringing it upon themselves by “nagging”. Women who complain about harassment
on the street or at work will be told that they “can’t take a joke”. Women who
are assaulted are told their own behaviour is the cause, and that they were
“asking for it”.
A campaign of intimidation
By now it
is obvious that extreme transactivism constitutes a broad and sustained
campaign against women who stand up for women’s rights. The threats made by
extreme transactivists like Baker are not merely theoretical. Men who harass
women under the banner of transactivism do not restrict themselves to screaming
abuse at women’s rallies: they wave signs with slogans such as “Decapitate
TERFs” and “Kill JK Rowling”. And on occasion they commit physical assault.
This
public intimidation and violence must be seen in the context of attempts –
often successful – to destroy the livelihood of any woman who speaks up for
women’s rights. On the internet, in the workplace and in schools, universities,
hospitals and other services, a woman labelled a “TERF” will be inundated with
sexual and violent threats. She will be told to recant and apologise.
If she
responds by explaining why it is important to retain protections for women and
girls, she may be reported to her employer and often to the police. Shockingly,
their powers of investigation are often then subverted to become tools of misogynistic
abuse and coercion of women.
The most
high-profile victim of this abuse is the author JK Rowling, who has written
carefully and compassionately about sex and gender and has received death
threats. She wrote: “We’re living through the most misogynistic period I’ve
experienced.”
But
thousands of ordinary women have been targeted too. In 2018 it was revealed
that a Facebook group of academics acting in the name of “trans rights” were
targeting gender-critical academics such as Professor Kathleen Stock. One
member said: “File a hate crime report against her, and then the chairman and
vice-chair [of her department].” Another said: “Drag them over the f*****g
coals.”
We call
on you, prime minister, to lead the fightback. We
urge you to
condemn the violence and intimidation against gender-critical women, to commit
to addressing it and to open a call for evidence.
Yours sincerely
Maya
Forstater, executive director, Sex Matters
Helen Joyce, director of advocacy, Sex Matters, author of Trans:
when ideology meets reality
Naomi Cunningham, barrister, chair, Sex Matters
Baroness Bray of Coln
Baroness Finn
Joan Smith, author and journalist, co-chair of the Mayor of London’s VAWG board
2013–2021
Karen Ingala Smith, CEO nia, author of Defending Women’s
Spaces
Dr Shonagh Dillon, CEO Aurora New Dawn
Nimco Ali, FGM survivor, author, co-founder, the Five Foundation
Johann Lamont, former leader, Scottish Labour, MSP 1999-2021
Jenny Marra, Scottish Labour MSP, 2011-2021
Joan McAlpine, journalist and former MSP
Julie Bindel, journalist, author and feminist campaigner against male violence
Dame Jenni Murray DBE, journalist and broadcaster
Beatrix Campbell OBE, writer and broadcaster
Kathleen Stock, writer
Victoria Smith, writer
Susan Dalgaty, journalist
Jane Clare Jones, Centre for Feminist Thought
Kate Scottow, free-speech campaigner
Sharron Davies MBE, athlete, Olympic medalist
Mara Yamauchi, athlete, two-time olympian
Judith Green, co-founder and director, Woman’s Place UK
Lucy Masoud, barrister and director, Woman’s Place UK
Kim Thomas, director, Woman’s Place UK
Nicola Williams, Fair Play For Women
Fiona McAnena, Fair Play For Women
Kate Harris, co-founder, LGB Alliance
Bev Jackson, co-founder, LGB Alliance
Kate Barker, CEO, LGB Alliance
Bronwen Evans, LGB Alliance Cymru
Stephanie Davies-Arai BEM, Transgender Trend
Shelley Charlesworth, Transgender Trend
Tanya Carter and Tracy Shaw, Safe Schools Alliance
Heather Binning, Women’s Rights Network
Trina Budge, co-director, For Women Scotland
Marion Calder, co-director, For Women Scotland
Susan Smith, co-director, For Women Scotland
Lucy Hunter Blackburn, policy analyst, MurrayBlackburnMackenzie
Lisa Mackenzie, policy analyst, MurrayBlackburnMackenzie
Kath Murray, policy analyst and criminologist,
MurrayBlackburnMackenzie/University of Edinburgh
Clare Blom, co-founder, Women Won’t Wheesht
Jenny Reilly, co-founder, Women Won’t Wheesht
Julie Marshall, co-founder, Women Won’t Wheesht
Caroline McAllister, co-founder, Women Won’t Wheesht
Janice Williams, OBJECT
Sarah Vine KC, on behalf of Legal Feminist
Stella O’Malley, Genspect
James Esses, co-founder, Thoughtful Therapists
Chris Goddard, Thoughtful Therapists
Karen Varley, founder and director, Conservatives For Women
Jeannette Towey, director, Conservatives For Women
Alice Bondi, Labour Women’s Declaration working group
Dr Hannah Ryan, Labour Women’s Declaration working group
Mary Curran, Labour Women’s Declaration working group
Jane Ayres, Labour Women’s Declaration working group
Bronwen Davies, Labour Women’s Declaration Cymru
Dr Zoe Hollowood, Liberal Voice for Women
Allison Jenner, Liberal Voice for Women
Maureen O’Hara, WDI-UK
Lynne Harne, Lesbian Rights Alliance
Carol Angharad, Lesbian Labour
Paula Boulton, Lesbian Labour and Lesbian Fightback
Stella Foster, Lesbian Labour
M Cameron, Scottish Feminist Network
K Cotter, Scottish Feminist Network
Dr Lorraine Douglas, Scottish Lesbians
Jenny Willmott, Scottish Lesbians
Dawn Furness, environmentalist and women’s rights campaigner
Ali Morris, Merched Cymru
Michael Conroy, Men at Work
Sarah Phillimore, barrister, co-founder Fair Cop
Harry Miller, co-founder Fair Cop
William Mackesy, Alumni for Free Speech
Graham Linehan, comedy writer
James Dreyfus, actor
Andrew Doyle, comedian, author and broadcaster
Denise Fahmy, Freedom in the Arts
Rosie Kay, Freedom in the Arts
James Chiavarini, restauranteur
Rachel Rooney, children’s author and teacher
Jane Harris, author
Gillian Philip, writer
Rose George, author
Malcolm Clark, documentary maker
Professor Alice Sullivan, University College London
Professor Sarah Pedersen, Robert Gordon University
Professor Jo Pheonix, Reading University
Dr Shereen Benjamin, University of Edinburgh
Dr Heather Brunskell-Evans, author of Transgender Body
Politics
Michelle Shipworth, associate professor, University College London
Dr Michael Biggs, University of Oxford, Sex Matters board member
Dr Emma Hilton, University of Manchester, Sex Matters board member
Anya Palmer, barrister
Peter Daly, solicitor
Monica Kurnatowska, solicitor, Sex Matters advisory group member
Rebecca Bull, solicitor, Sex Matters board member
Audrey Ludwig, solicitor
Catherine Hawkins, solicitor
Diane Holyoak, teacher and feminist campaigner for women’s and girls’ sex-based
rights
Jo Campbell, carer and lesbian activist
Venice Allan, women’s rights campaigner
Ann Sinnott, Authentic Equity Alliance
Raquel Rosario Sánchez, Centre for Gender and Violence Research
Milli Hill, author and feminist campaigner
Tracey Smith, Labour Women’s Declaration Working Group and Sheffield GC Network
Lynn Alderson, Labour Women’s Declaration working group
Dennis Noel Kavanagh, legal commentator and gay rights activist
Julia Casimo, chartered accountant, Sex Matters board member
Jenny Lindsay, poet, writer
Martin Carr, Sex Matters advisory group member
Frances Weetman, writer
Beck Laxton, freelance designer and editor
Jo Bartosch, assistant editor The Critic
Pilgrim Tucker, PhD researcher, Open University (campaigner and writer)
Northern Radfem Network on behalf of all our members.
Simon Briscoe, statistician, Sex Matters advisory group member
Cathy Devine, independent researcher, Sex Matters advisory group member
Helen Saxby, feminist writer
Jeni Harvey, feminist writer
Sonya Douglas, artist, writer, poet, Sex Matters advisory group member
Nicola Carr, feminist activist
Julia Williams, writer and editor
Prime
Minister, will you stand up to violence against women? - Sex Matters
(sex-matters.org)
